Skip to content
BiteRanked

Carlton · Updated 16 Oct 2026

The best Pasta in Carlton

Ranked from 10,782 reviews across 8 restaurants.

Pasta at Kaprica

The winner

Kaprica

Italian · Carlton

The prawn pasta at Kaprica in Carlton is a standout, frequently praised for its deliciousness and prompting repeat visits amongst hungry patrons.

reviews mention the Pasta
22
of them positive
59%
overall
Mixed

50 Grattan St, Carlton VIC 3053

Plan a visit

However, several reviewers note that the pasta could benefit from an extra hit of seasoning to fully elevate the flavour profile, suggesting a preference for bolder tastes. This bustling restaurant seems ideally suited to groups seeking a lively Italian experience and those who enjoy sharing pizzas alongside their main courses.

How it’s holding up

restaurants ranked
8
reviews across them
10,782
reviews mention the Pasta
129
last updated
16 Oct 2026
Mentions of the Pasta, month by monthPositiveNegative

115 of the 129 mentions of the Pasta have a date within these months; the chart shows those.

The 10,782 reviews are every review these restaurants have, about any dish, so not all of them were read for this guide. We collected 371 of them, which can include more than one review from the same person. 22 reviews mention the Pasta at Kaprica. Rankings are based on public reviews, not visits.

Also worth a trip

The other 7 restaurants ranked for Pasta in Carlton, in order.

  1. Number 2: Café Corretto – Italian RestaurantCarltonPasta at Café Corretto is frequently praised for its perfectly cooked texture and rich, satisfying garlic flavours.18 reviews mention the Pasta
    Pasta at Café Corretto – Italian Restaurant

    Italian · 227 Lygon St, Carlton VIC 3053

    Pasta at Café Corretto is frequently praised for its perfectly cooked texture and rich, satisfying garlic flavours. Staff consistently serve the pasta fresh and hot, alongside friendly service, although some found it left them feeling quite full.

    83% of reviews of the Pasta are positive

  2. Number 3: Mercadante Woodfired PizzeriaCarltonPeople at Mercadante Woodfired Pizzeria rave about their pasta, particularly noting perfectly cooked al dente dishes brimming with flavour and rich sauces like the Spaghetti Gamberi.13 reviews mention the Pasta

    Italian · 123 Lygon St, Carlton VIC 3053

    People at Mercadante Woodfired Pizzeria rave about their pasta, particularly noting perfectly cooked al dente dishes brimming with flavour and rich sauces like the Spaghetti Gamberi. The welcoming staff and relaxed atmosphere contribute to a positive dining experience, as evidenced by several diners expressing a desire to return for more.

    92% of reviews of the Pasta are positive

  3. Number 4: Da Guido La PastaCarltonPeople consistently praise the pasta at Da Guido La Pasta, noting a marked improvement with each dish and an assured, earthy flavour profile.18 reviews mention the Pasta
    Pasta at Da Guido La Pasta

    Italian · 130 Lygon St, Carlton VIC 3053

    People consistently praise the pasta at Da Guido La Pasta, noting a marked improvement with each dish and an assured, earthy flavour profile. The welcoming service and relaxed atmosphere on the terrace balcony contribute to a pleasurable dining experience for those visiting from afar.

    94% of reviews of the Pasta are positive

    Closed - Opens 6 pm

  4. Number 5: Leonardo's Pizza PalaceCarltonPeople frequently praise Leonardo’s Pizza Palace pasta for its authentic taste and amazing texture.14 reviews mention the Pasta
    Pasta at Leonardo's Pizza Palace

    Italian · 29 Grattan St, Carlton VIC 3053

    People frequently praise Leonardo’s Pizza Palace pasta for its authentic taste and amazing texture. The team provides excellent service, and one reviewer noted a particularly fluffy dough, though some found the pizza crust exceptionally tasty.

    86% of reviews of the Pasta are positive

  5. Number 6: Papa Gino'sCarltonPeople consistently praise the generous portions and authentic, traditional flavours of Papa Gino’s pasta dishes, particularly the extensive 3-pasta combo.23 reviews mention the Pasta
    Pasta at Papa Gino's

    Italian · 221 Lygon St, Carlton VIC 3053

    People consistently praise the generous portions and authentic, traditional flavours of Papa Gino’s pasta dishes, particularly the extensive 3-pasta combo. Guests describe the food as tasting like home-cooked goodness and appreciate the classic Italian eatery's warm atmosphere and large servings.

    83% of reviews of the Pasta are positive

  6. Number 7: Cafe CavallinoCarltonThe Giardini pasta is a standout, frequently praised for its delicious flavour and enjoyable texture, especially when enjoyed on a chilly evening.12 reviews mention the Pasta
    Pasta at Cafe Cavallino

    Italian · 181-183 Lygon St, Carlton VIC 3053

    The Giardini pasta is a standout, frequently praised for its delicious flavour and enjoyable texture, especially when enjoyed on a chilly evening. Guests consistently highlight the friendly service and quick food arrival times as key elements of their positive dining experience at Cafe Cavallino.

    83% of reviews of the Pasta are positive

  7. Number 8: La Spaghettata RestaurantCarltonLa Spaghettata Restaurant is a top-rated spot for Pasta in Carlton.9 reviews mention the Pasta
    Pasta at La Spaghettata Restaurant

    Italian · 238 Lygon St, Carlton VIC 3053

    La Spaghettata Restaurant is a top-rated spot for Pasta in Carlton.

    100% of reviews of the Pasta are positive

    Open - Closes 12 am

The longer read

What the reviews say

What the reviews say about the best Pasta in Carlton, restaurant by restaurant.

Why it leads

Why Kaprica is the pick for Pasta

The prawn pasta at Kaprica in Carlton is a standout, frequently praised for its deliciousness and prompting repeat visits amongst hungry patrons. However, several reviewers note that the pasta could benefit from an extra hit of seasoning to fully elevate the flavour profile, suggesting a preference for bolder tastes. This bustling restaurant seems ideally suited to groups seeking a lively Italian experience and those who enjoy sharing pizzas alongside their main courses.

The alternatives

Where the other Pasta spots shine

Not everyone wants the same Pasta. These are the clearest differences reviewers point to among the next-best places.

  • Café Corretto – Italian Restaurant: Pasta at Café Corretto is frequently praised for its perfectly cooked texture and rich, satisfying garlic flavours.
  • Mercadante Woodfired Pizzeria: People at Mercadante Woodfired Pizzeria rave about their pasta, particularly noting perfectly cooked al dente dishes brimming with flavour and rich sauces like the Spaghetti Gamberi.
  • Da Guido La Pasta: People consistently praise the pasta at Da Guido La Pasta, noting a marked improvement with each dish and an assured, earthy flavour profile.
  • Leonardo's Pizza Palace: People frequently praise Leonardo’s Pizza Palace pasta for its authentic taste and amazing texture.

How to choose

Choosing Pasta in Carlton

Treat this as a shortlist as well as a winner: Kaprica has the strongest reviews for the Pasta, and the others are where reviewers found different strengths across Carlton.

  • 10,782 reviews across 8 restaurants ranked; that total covers every dish they serve, not only the Pasta.
  • 22 reviews mention the Pasta at Kaprica, and 59% of them are positive.

Questions people ask

What is the best Pasta in Carlton?

Kaprica in Carlton is currently ranked #1 for Pasta in Carlton, among 8 candidates in our available dataset. The prawn pasta at Kaprica in Carlton is a standout, frequently praised for its deliciousness and prompting repeat visits amongst hungry patrons. However, several reviewers note that the pasta could benefit from an extra hit of seasoning to fully elevate the flavour profile, suggesting a preference for bolder tastes.

Which other Pasta places in Carlton come close?

Café Corretto – Italian Restaurant, Mercadante Woodfired Pizzeria, Da Guido La Pasta round out the top of the ranking. Each earned strong dish-specific praise in recent reviews — the full shortlist below covers 8 ranked restaurants.

How is the best Pasta in Carlton decided?

BiteRanked compares candidates using available restaurant ratings and dish mentions. Listing review totals are not collected review counts. Coverage is incomplete; the recorded ranking update is 2026-10-16. Read our methodology for scoring and limitations.

How we rank

Each restaurant’s score combines its overall rating with how often its reviews mention the Pasta. How positive those reviews are, and how that is changing, is shown for context and is not part of the score. Rankings are based on public reviews, not visits.

Read the full method