← New searchThe winner · Analysed 13,785 reviews● Updated 2026-05-01
Best Pizzain Carlton
Pizza restaurant · Brunswick East
465 Lygon St
Golden Pizza
Traditional and gourmet toppings, plus burgers and schnitzel, cooked in an unpretentious kitchen.
Score
8.6
Mentions
5
Sentiment
90%
“Sure. The other reviews are good but what are the really like? Honestly, the pizza is spectacular. The dining area, whether inside or out, is rudimentary but that didn’t matter if you are after quality, tasty pizza. We had their Golden Super Special pizza (large: $20) and it was”
— C A Hoop
Runners up
Top 10 in Carlton
- 02
Roccella Italian Restaurant East Melbourne
158 Clarendon St, East Melbourne
3 mentions
8.4
↓ - 03
11 Inch Pizza
7a/353 Little Collins St, Melbourne
4 mentions
8.3
↓ - 04
Leonardo's Pizza Palace
29 Grattan St, Carlton
5 mentions
8.3
↓ - 05
Deep End Pizza
412a Brunswick St, Fitzroy
5 mentions
8.2
↓ - 06
Romo Pizza Bar
21 Katherine Pl, Melbourne
5 mentions
8.2
↓ - 07
Matto Napoletano Pizzeria
26 Liverpool St, Melbourne
5 mentions
8.2
↓ - 08
Primo
104 High St, Northcote
5 mentions
8.2
↓ - 09
🍕 Piccolino Woodfired Pizza & Homemade Pasta - Italian Restaurant Fitzroy North
148 Scotchmer St, Fitzroy North
4 mentions
8.1
↓ - 10
Figlia
335 Lygon St, Brunswick East
3 mentions
8.1
↓
Sources
10 reviews from Google, blogs, Reddit and food guides.
Signal
5 mentions of "pizza" tied to Golden Pizza.
Score
Weighted by recency, sentiment polarity and authority of the source.