Our pick · 21 ranked candidates● Updated 2026-09-02

Best pizza in New York

Name: The Pie Guy Pizza
Address: 83-85 Baxter St, New York, NY 10013, United States, New York, AU
Telephone: +1 646-895-9507

Compare 21 ranked candidates for pizza in New York, using the available dish evidence. Check the mentions, coverage and venue details before choosing.

Plan your visit to The Pie Guy Pizza

83-85 Baxter St, New York, NY 10013, United States

Dish price is not verified. Check the restaurant’s current menu. Confirm opening hours and dish availability before travelling.

Get directions Compare alternatives Understand the evidence

The verdict at a glance

Top 5 for pizza in New York

Full list ↓

1The Pie Guy PizzaNew YorkA perfectly crispy outer crust gives way to a soft, airy interior that carries incredibly fresh and flavourful...9.7
2SIMÒ PIZZA - UNIVERSITYNew YorkThe clearest pattern in the excerpts is the thin, wood-fired crust and incredible sauce found on classics like...8.9
3Stage Door PizzeriaNew YorkThe reviews point most directly to the pizza for its incredible quality, with some even claiming it surpasses...8.8
4LTD Pizza and BarNew YorkThe LTD pizza shines with an otherworldly combination of pepperoni, hot honey, and flavourful homemade...8.5
5Stretch PizzaNew YorkChef Wylie DuFresne delivers incredibly flavourful, thin, and flaky crusts that make these slices some of...8.4

#1 Ranked

Italian · New York

83-85 Baxter St, New York, NY 10013, United States

The Pie Guy Pizza

A perfectly crispy outer crust gives way to a soft, airy interior that carries incredibly fresh and flavourful toppings like Buffalo chicken and savory meat lovers. Every slice delivers a balanced, delicious bite that pairs high-quality ingredients with an impressive value for both quick slices and whole pies. While New York is crowded with mediocre slices, this spot secures its top rank through a consistent, mouthwatering texture that makes every single bite feel like a premium experience.

Winner Verdict

Overwhelmingly Positive

Score

9.7

Mentions

Sentiment

95%

Plan the visit

Website

Hours

Closed - Opens 10 am

Phone

+1 646-895-9507

Dated dish reviews

How it holds over time

Holding steady

Based on the recent feedback, The Pie Guy Pizza appears to be maintaining a consistently positive reputation for its pizza. While there’s a slight increase in positive comments, particularly regarding a perfectly crispy crust and fresh toppings, suggesting a possible improvement, the overall trend indicates a steady level of customer satisfaction.

1–4 years ago

100%

positive across 13 dated dish reviews

Last 12 months

92%

positive across 24 dated dish reviews

Evidence behind this ranking

Updated 2026-09-02

Collected review count: not separately recorded for every candidate in this ranking.

Dated Review Activity (last 24 months)

Very Positive

1,180 of 1,427 mentions have usable recent dates (0 undated, 247 older).

PositiveNegative

This dataset contains 21 ranked candidates and 113,166 source-listed restaurant reviews. That total includes other dishes and is not the number of review texts collected. 37 recorded dish mentions are associated with The Pie Guy Pizza. Coverage is incomplete; a ranking is not a firsthand review.

How scores, review counts and update dates work →

Runners up

Top 21 around New York

02
SIMÒ PIZZA - UNIVERSITY
The clearest pattern in the excerpts is the thin, wood-fired crust and incredible sauce found on classics like the Margherita and mushroom varieties.
75 University Pl, New York, NY 10003, United States
8.9
42 mentions
↓
03
Stage Door Pizzeria
The reviews point most directly to the pizza for its incredible quality, with some even claiming it surpasses legendary local competitors and international standards.
26 Vesey St 2nd Floor, New York, NY 10007, United States
8.8
40 mentions
↓
04
LTD Pizza and Bar
The LTD pizza shines with an otherworldly combination of pepperoni, hot honey, and flavourful homemade stracciatella that approaches perfection.
225 Hudson St, New York, NY 10013, United States
8.5
41 mentions
↓
05
Stretch Pizza
Chef Wylie DuFresne delivers incredibly flavourful, thin, and flaky crusts that make these slices some of Manhattan's best.
331 Park Ave S, New York, NY 10010, United States
8.4
37 mentions
↓
06
BarDough
BarDough earns its high ranking through incredibly flavourful pizzas featuring perfectly crisp crusts and fresh, premium toppings like truffle and garden vegetables.
350 W 46th St, New York, NY 10036, United States
8.2
35 mentions
↓
07
La Pizza Italia 🇮🇹
The clearest pattern in the excerpts is the thin, crispy crust and the high quality of fresh, delicious toppings like the pesto roni.
625 9th Ave, New York, NY 10036, United States
8.2
38 mentions
↓
08
Underground Pizza
The clearest pattern in the excerpts is the pizza for its perfectly crispy crust and soft, chewy dough topped with flavourful, fresh ingredients.
3 Hanover Square #2615, New York, NY 10004, United States
8.1
48 mentions
↓
09
Eddie's Pizza
Diners rave about the incredible bar pies, specifically praising the addition of spicy cherry peppers and the unique fried eggplant pizza.
2048 Hillside Ave., New Hyde Park, NY 11040, United States
8.0
35 mentions
↓
10
Filaga
Filaga earns its high rank through incredibly fresh, flavourful toppings and light, fantastic dough that leaves diners craving more.
75 9th Ave, New York, NY 10011, United States
8.0
40 mentions
↓
11
Una Pizza Napoletana
The pizza features incredibly well-made crusts and high-quality ingredients sourced from Italy or local farms.
175 Orchard St, New York, NY 10002, United States
7.9
36 mentions
↓
12
Little Charli
The artisan pizza shines with incredible toppings, particularly the irresistible chocolate and marshmallow dessert pie that guests crave.
271 Bleecker St, New York, NY 10014, United States
7.8
42 mentions
↓
13
Pizzazz
Pizzazz offers incredible individual-sized pies that evoke the authentic taste of Naples through fresh, Italian-style crusts and toppings.
38 Union Sq E, New York, NY 10003, United States
7.7
43 mentions
↓
14
Tappo NYC Thin Crust Pizza
Tappo NYC earns high marks for its wonderfully crunchy thin crust topped with savory meats, fresh mozzarella, and flavourful ingredients like roasted garlic.
32 E 21st St, New York, NY 10010, United States
7.6
38 mentions
↓
15
ANDIAMO PIZZA
The clearest pattern in the excerpts is the pizza for its flavourful, tangy sauce, perfectly balanced toppings, and a satisfyingly crisp crust.
818 6th Ave, New York, NY 10001, United States
7.5
42 mentions
↓
16
Little Italy Pizza
The recurring detail is the perfect balance of crispy crust, gooey cheese, and flavourful red sauce found in their thick Sicilian and Grandma slices.
167 W 48th St, New York, NY 10036, United States
7.5
46 mentions
↓
17
Patzeria Perfect Pizza
Patzeria Perfect Pizza delivers exceptional slices featuring marvelous bread and a perfect crispy, oily texture that satisfies any classic craving.
231 W 46th St, New York, NY 10036, United States
7.5
41 mentions
↓
18
Best Pizza
The reviews point most directly to the thin, charred crust and the perfect balance of high-quality ingredients in every flavourful bite.
33 Havemeyer St, Brooklyn, NY 11211, United States
7.4
38 mentions
↓
19
Carnegie Pizza
The recurring detail is the crispy crust, flavourful toppings, and that classic New York cheese stretch found in every slice.
200 W 41st St, New York, NY 10036, United States
7.4
45 mentions
↓
20
Don Antonio
The flavourful sauce, fresh mozzarella, and authentic New York style crust make every pie an incredible experience.
Don Antonio's Pizza, 309 W 50th St, New York, NY 10019, United States
7.4
46 mentions
↓
21
Nuovo York Pizza
The pizza features an amazingly crisp, flop-free crust loaded with premium toppings like fresh burrata, arugula, and savory pesto pepperoni.
105 E 9th St, New York, NY 10003, United States
7.4
43 mentions
↓

Review guide

The evidence behind the best pizza in New York

This guide expands the ranking into the review patterns behind the best pizza in New York, using only pages with enough restaurant and review signal to support a fuller breakdown.

Reviews

113,166+

Restaurants

Updated

2026-09-02

Why the winner leads

Why The Pie Guy Pizza ranks #1 for pizza

How the shortlist compares

Where the other top pizza spots stand out

The rest of the ranking still matters because pizza searches are rarely one-size-fits-all. These are the clearest review-backed differences among the next-best places.

SIMÒ PIZZA - UNIVERSITY: The clearest pattern in the excerpts is the thin, wood-fired crust and incredible sauce found on classics like the Margherita and mushroom varieties.
Stage Door Pizzeria: The reviews point most directly to the pizza for its incredible quality, with some even claiming it surpasses legendary local competitors and international standards.
LTD Pizza and Bar: The LTD pizza shines with an otherworldly combination of pepperoni, hot honey, and flavourful homemade stracciatella that approaches perfection.
Stretch Pizza: Chef Wylie DuFresne delivers incredibly flavourful, thin, and flaky crusts that make these slices some of Manhattan's best.

How to choose

Choosing pizza in New York

Use this ranking as a shortlist, not just a winner announcement: The Pie Guy Pizza is the strongest overall signal, while the runners up show where reviewers found different strengths across New York.

113,166 source-listed restaurant reviews are associated with 21 ranked candidates; these are not all collected review texts.
The Pie Guy Pizza has 37 pizza mentions and a 95% sentiment score.
The current review verdict is overwhelmingly positive.

Search another dish→

Quick answers

Frequently asked questions

What is the best pizza in New York?

The Pie Guy Pizza in New York is currently ranked #1 for pizza in New York, among 21 candidates in our available dataset. A perfectly crispy outer crust gives way to a soft, airy interior that carries incredibly fresh and flavourful toppings like Buffalo chicken and savory meat lovers. Every slice delivers a balanced, delicious bite that pairs high-quality ingredients with an impressive value for both quick slices and whole pies.

Which other pizza places in New York come close?

SIMÒ PIZZA - UNIVERSITY, Stage Door Pizzeria, LTD Pizza and Bar round out the top of the ranking. Each earned strong dish-specific praise in recent reviews — the full shortlist below covers 21 ranked restaurants.

How is the best pizza in New York decided?

BiteRanked compares candidates using available restaurant ratings and dish mentions. Listing review totals are not collected review counts. Coverage is incomplete; the recorded ranking update is 2026-09-02. Read our methodology for scoring and limitations.