The best pizza in Melbourne

Italian · 146 Clarendon St, South Melbourne VIC 3006

Liberty Slices South Melbourne’s New York style pizza boasts a wonderfully chewy dough, perfectly cooked to a crisp yet tender texture with a generous topping of Wisconsin cheese. Reviewers praise the aroma of fresh tomato sauce and the vibrant flavour of the toppings, alongside the satisfying portion size and excellent value for money, providing a comforting and familiar experience. Unlike many Melbourne pizza offerings, Liberty Slices delivers a genuinely authentic New York-style pizza experience, closely mirroring the quality and taste found in iconic NYC pizzerias.

Italian · shop 105r/224 A'Beckett St, West Melbourne VIC 3003

Milano Restaurant’s Pepperoni Pizza boasts a noticeably crisp crust, achieving a delightful balance between airy texture and satisfying chewiness, complemented by a generous layer of melted, savory cheese. Reviewers praise the consistently high quality and generous portion sizes, often noting the aroma of fresh ingredients and a pleasant spice level, particularly in their hot and spicy variations. Despite some inconsistencies in flavor profiles, Milano distinguishes itself through its genuine commitment to traditional Italian pizza-making, offering a reliably comforting and approachable experience in Melbourne’s diverse dining scene.

Italian · 47 Spensley St, Clifton Hill VIC 3068

The Donatello pizza at Pizza Shop in Clifton Hill boasts a wonderfully crisp, almost blistered crust, achieved thanks to their electric oven. Customers rave about the intense aroma and generous toppings, particularly the pepperoni, alongside quick service and a lively, bustling atmosphere reflecting the excitement of the clientele. Despite the occasional operational hiccups, the restaurant’s reliably delicious pizzas, combined with its energetic vibe, firmly establishes it as a standout choice for a satisfying Melbourne meal.

Italian · 49 Bourke St, Melbourne VIC 3000

Pizza Vacanza’s pizzas boast a wonderfully light, airy dough that’s expertly baked in a stone oven, delivering a satisfyingly crisp texture and releasing a strong, authentic Italian aroma. Reviewers praise the generous portion sizes and fresh, high-quality toppings, particularly the excellent tuna pizzas, alongside the comforting, familiar taste that evokes a feeling of home. Unlike many Melbourne pizzerias, the restaurant's unwavering dedication to delivering a genuinely Italian experience, coupled with its approachable prices, creates a consistently enjoyable and intensely personal dining experience.

Italian · Shop 1, 207-361 Flinders St, Melbourne VIC 3000

Rozzis’ Flinders pizza boasts generously sized slices topped with vibrant, fresh ingredients, particularly noticeable in the quality of the mozzarella and scattered roasted red peppers. Reviewers frequently praise the comforting texture and satisfying portion size, alongside the aroma of the dough as it’s baked, making it a reliable choice for a quick bite near Flinders Station. Unlike many Melbourne pizza options, Rozzis stands out for its consistently friendly service, even during peak hours, offering a genuinely welcoming experience alongside its delicious pizza.

Italian · Shop 151A/211 La Trobe St, Melbourne VIC 3000

Rozzis Pizza near the State Library in Melbourne boasts a remarkably thin, crisp dough that holds a generous helping of toppings, particularly vibrant pepperoni, offering a satisfying chew. Customers praise the freshness and flavorful combinations, alongside a welcoming atmosphere and attentive service, often noting a generous portion size for the price. What truly distinguishes Rozzis is its ability to deliver a consistently enjoyable, uncomplicated pizza experience—a simple, well-executed delight that feels like a genuine neighborhood staple in a city brimming with pizza options.

Italian · 148 Exhibition St, Melbourne VIC 3000

Sal’s Authentic New York Pizza – Exhibition Street delivers a remarkably crisp, slightly charred crust, ideal for supporting generous portions of pepperoni and sausage. Reviewers praise the authentic New York style, noting the balanced flavor of the sauce, the satisfying spice from the toppings, and the overall comforting experience at a fair price. Unlike many Melbourne pizza offerings, Sal’s focuses on delivering a genuinely traditional, unadulterated New York-style pizza experience that faithfully replicates the taste and texture of its namesake city.

Italian · 59 Brunswick St, Fitzroy VIC 3065

Smoke & Slice’s zaatar pizza boasts a wonderfully fragrant, herbaceous crust generously layered with fresh, vibrant toppings, creating a satisfyingly textured experience. Reviewers praise the restaurant’s friendly atmosphere and affordable pricing, particularly noting the generous portion sizes and excellent flavor combinations alongside dishes like chicken pasta and lasagna. Unlike the many standard pizza offerings in Melbourne, Smoke & Slice distinguishes itself through its bold Middle Eastern-inspired flavor profiles and surprisingly high-quality execution for a neighbourhood pizzeria.

Italian · 78 Wellington Parade, East Melbourne VIC 3002

The Napoletana pizza at Queen Caterina Pizza e Birra boasts a wonderfully thin, yet yielding crust, showcasing the careful attention to texture and authentic Italian flavor. Reviewers praise the generous portions brimming with high-quality ingredients like smoked Virginia ham, hot salami, and bacon, alongside a vibrant, fresh tomato base, a welcome contrast to the heavier offerings nearby. This pizza stands apart due to its consistent commitment to delivering a deeply satisfying, slightly Neapolitan-leaning experience, providing exceptional value for a truly memorable meal in Melbourne.

Italian · 285 Racecourse Rd, Kensington VIC 3031

The Broken Oven’s pizzas boast generously sized, blistered crusts, often cooked to a satisfyingly crisp edge, while the truffle shuffle pizza offers a decadent, earthy aroma. Reviewers frequently praise the fresh, high-quality toppings and the satisfying portion sizes, particularly noting the pepperoni pizza with hot honey as a standout choice. Unlike many Melbourne pizza joints, The Broken Oven consistently delivers a truly exceptional experience, fueled by its commitment to quality ingredients and a focused menu that elevates simple pizzas to something truly special.

Closed - Opens 4:30 pm

Italian · 1/660 Elizabeth St, Melbourne VIC 3000

Duke Pizza’s American Boy pizza boasts generously sized portions with a delightfully crisp, slightly charred crust, perfectly complementing the tender, barbecued chicken and vibrant, fresh toppings. Reviewers consistently praised the restaurant’s attentive service and welcoming atmosphere, noting the care taken in preparing and delivering each pizza, often with direct driver intervention to ensure freshness. What truly sets Duke Pizza apart is their commitment to consistently delivering high-quality, flavorful pizzas, particularly their innovative combinations, offering a genuinely satisfying experience for those seeking a reliable and enjoyable meal in Melbourne.

Italian · 1/301 Swanston St, Melbourne VIC 3000

Dom’s Social Club’s Stracciatella pizza boasts generously layered fresh mozzarella and ricotta, creating a delightfully creamy texture that contrasts beautifully with the slightly charred crust. Reviewers praise the pizzeria’s authentic atmosphere, reminiscent of a Chicago deep dish experience, and highlight the sizable portions, offering a comforting and intensely flavorful meal. Situated in a discreet CBD location, this establishment distinguishes itself through its dedicated focus on elevated, traditional Italian pizza, providing a genuinely immersive and nostalgic experience unlike many other Melbourne options.

Closed - Opens 5 pm Wed

Italian · 1/59 Stanley Ave, Mount Waverley VIC 3149

Not Another Pizza Place’s Neapolitan-style pizzas boast a delightfully chewy, slightly blistered crust, achieved through their careful attention to base hydration and texture. Customers rave about generous portions, particularly the Capricciosa, layered with fresh ingredients like pear and a rich, decadent meat sauce, alongside friendly service and a comforting atmosphere. What truly sets this Melbourne pizzeria apart is their dedication to authentic, high-quality ingredients and a consistently exceptional wood-fired pizza experience, mirroring the best Naples has to offer.

Closed - Opens 5 pm Wed

Italian · 831d Bourke St, Docklands VIC 3008

San Marzano Pizzeria’s large pizzas boast a beautifully charred sourdough crust, showcasing impressive oven spring and a delightfully airy interior, a texture reviewers repeatedly praised. The vibrant tomato base, combined with generous toppings like pepperoni and fresh vegetables, delivers a balanced and intensely flavorful experience, frequently complemented by the smoky aroma from the wood-fired oven. Unlike many Melbourne pizzerias, San Marzano's dedication to authentic, customizable pizzas and a consistently high-quality product creates a uniquely satisfying and deeply rooted experience for locals.

Italian · 2 S Wharf Dr, Docklands VIC 3008

Pizze Société’s “The Lot” pizza boasts a remarkably thick, yielding crust generously topped with a vibrant array of ingredients, creating a substantial and comforting experience. Reviewers frequently praised the restaurant’s value, noting the expansive pizza selection and affordable prices, alongside the aroma of fresh ingredients and a satisfying textural contrast. Unlike many Melbourne pizza offerings, Pizze Société’s bold flavor combinations and generous portion sizes deliver a genuinely intense, almost chaotic, Italian experience, reflecting a passionate dedication to a classic style.

Italian · C/104 Park St, South Melbourne VIC 3205

Wise Guys Pizza 'n' Pasta’s “Butch’s Meat Treat” pizza features a generous layering of bacon, ham, and salami, often cooked well-done to customer preference, offering a satisfyingly meaty experience. Reviewers praise the value, with a large pizza and Parma frequently costing around $35, and highlight the freshness of their salads and the appealing aroma of the herbs and spices used. Despite some delivery issues, the consistently flavorful pizzas, particularly the generous portions and careful topping selection, establish Wise Guys as a reliably tasty and affordable option in Melbourne’s diverse pizza scene.

Italian · 211 La Trobe St, Melbourne VIC 3000

Pazzi’s pizzas stand out with a noticeably crispy, yet slightly firm crust, achieved through what appears to be a deliberate baking method. Reviewers praise the generous portion sizes and the fresh toppings, particularly noting a satisfying aroma and a taste reminiscent of New York-style pizza. Unlike many food court options in Melbourne, Pazzi’s focuses on delivering a quality pizza experience with a dedicated display of preparation, making it a reliably tasty and comforting choice.

Italian · 1/377 Lonsdale St, Melbourne VIC 3000

Crust pizza in Melbourne CBD boasts a delightfully crisp, slightly charred crust that holds a generous layering of fresh toppings, particularly noticeable in the bright tomato flavor. Reviewers appreciate the consistently friendly service and the value of lunchtime specials like the small pizza and drink deal, while some found the sauce to be sparsely applied and lacking depth. Despite inconsistencies in execution, Crust distinguishes itself with its reliably speedy service and the noticeable freshness of its ingredients, offering a dependable late-night option for pizza cravings within the city.

Italian · 274 Clarendon St, South Melbourne VIC 3205

Patony Pizza’s number 13 pizza boasts generously layered, shredded ham alongside pineapple, achieving a delightful crispness from the oven’s heat. Reviewers appreciated the intensely fresh dough and the satisfying portion size, describing it as a comforting and straightforward meal offering genuine value. Unlike many Melbourne pizzerias, Patony’s stands out for its willingness to cater to individual requests, even going above and beyond to accommodate a customer’s specific preferences and offering a genuinely warm experience.

Italian · 211 Elizabeth St, Melbourne VIC 3000

Domino's Pizza Elizabeth St is a top-rated spot for pizza in Melbourne.