New search2 ranked Italian dishes117,362+ reviews analysedUpdated 2026-08-07
Italian restaurantsin New York
The strongest Italian places in New York, organised by the dishes people actually search for: pizza and Parma.
Ranked dishes
2
Reviews analysed
117,362+
Winning restaurants
2
Best dishes
Italian rankings in New York
Review-backed picks
Best pizza
Best pizza in New York
Italian · New York
The Pie Guy Pizza
Across a vast range of reviews, diners consistently praised the quality and flavour profiles of The Pie Guy Pizza's offerings.
Mentions
37
Sentiment
95%
Reviews
113,166+
Best Parma
Best Parma in New York
Italian · New York
La Bella Vita
Despite limited mentions, the core appeal of La Bella Vita’s Parma lies in its convincingly traditional preparation and generous topping distribution.
Mentions
2
Sentiment
0%
Reviews
4,196+
Dish guides
MayRee
Best cocktails by location
MayRee leads the cocktails ranking in New York. Compare 31 locations from one hub.
Golden Steer at One Fifth
Best steak by location
Golden Steer at One Fifth leads the steak ranking in New York. Compare 27 locations from one hub.
Joe's Home of Soup Dumplings
Best soup by location
Joe's Home of Soup Dumplings leads the soup ranking in New York. Compare 68 locations from one hub.
Schaller's Stube Sausage Bar
Best beer by location
Schaller's Stube Sausage Bar leads the beer ranking in New York. Compare 35 locations from one hub.
Cô Lạc
Best fried rice by location
Cô Lạc leads the fried rice ranking in New York. Compare 41 locations from one hub.
Nounou Noodle Bar
Best noodle by location
Nounou Noodle Bar leads the noodle ranking in New York. Compare 59 locations from one hub.
Top winners
More guides
More in New York
Best International restaurants in New York
More in New York
Best Thai restaurants in New York
More in New York
Best Vietnamese restaurants in New York
More in New York
Best Generic restaurants in New York
More in New York
Best Beverage restaurants in New York
More in New York
Best n/a restaurants in New York
Italian by city
Best Italian restaurants in Melbourne
Italian by city
Best Italian restaurants in Sydney
Italian by city
Best Italian restaurants in Brisbane
Italian by city
Best Italian restaurants in Perth
Italian by city
Best Italian restaurants in Carlton
Italian by city
Best Italian restaurants in Southbank