New search3 ranked Italian dishes19,098+ reviews analysedUpdated 2026-09-02
Italian restaurantsin Carlton
The strongest Italian places in Carlton, organised by the dishes people actually search for: Pasta, pizza and Parma.
Ranked dishes
3
Reviews analysed
19,098+
Winning restaurants
3
Best dishes
Italian rankings in Carlton
Review-backed picks
Best Pasta
Best Pasta in Carlton
Italian · Carlton
Kaprica
The prawn pasta at Kaprica in Carlton is a standout, frequently praised for its deliciousness and prompting repeat visits amongst hungry patrons. However, several reviewers note that the pasta could benefit from an extra hit of seasoning to fully elevate the flavour profile, suggesting a preference for bolder tastes.
Mentions
19
Sentiment
58%
Reviews
8,410+
Best pizza
Best pizza in Carlton
Italian · Carlton
Leonardo's Pizza Palace
Leonardo’s Pizza Palace in Carlton is delivering a pizza experience that's clearly resonating with locals, judging by the high volume of mentions – over forty across reviews. the review evidence points to the generous topping amounts and the perfectly crisp base, describing it as ideal for sharing amongst friends or family.
Mentions
48
Sentiment
94%
Reviews
8,148+
Best Parma
Best Parma in Carlton
Italian · Carlton
Café Corretto – Italian Restaurant
The Parma at Café Corretto in Carlton is proving a particular favourite, with one reviewer describing it as “so good” when enjoyed alongside ham. However, diners should be aware that the nutella crepe experienced some issues being potentially undercooked – a minor variation within an otherwise well-received menu.
Mentions
1
Sentiment
100%
Reviews
2,540+
Dish guides
Boogie House Hotpot
Best hot pot by location
Boogie House Hotpot leads the hot pot ranking in Carlton. Compare 9 locations from one hub.
Kaprica
Best Pasta by location
Kaprica leads the Pasta ranking in Carlton. Compare 23 locations from one hub.
Leonardo's Pizza Palace
Best pizza by location
Leonardo's Pizza Palace leads the pizza ranking in Carlton. Compare 28 locations from one hub.
Amie Bakery Cafe Melbourne University
Best steak by location
Amie Bakery Cafe Melbourne University leads the steak ranking in Carlton. Compare 37 locations from one hub.
Laksa House 118
Best Fried Chicken by location
Laksa House 118 leads the Fried Chicken ranking in Carlton. Compare 36 locations from one hub.
Laksa House 118
Best curry by location
Laksa House 118 leads the curry ranking in Carlton. Compare 56 locations from one hub.
Top winners
More guides
More in Carlton
Best Chinese restaurants in Carlton
More in Carlton
Best International restaurants in Carlton
More in Carlton
Best American restaurants in Carlton
More in Carlton
Best Vietnamese restaurants in Carlton
More in Carlton
Best Thai restaurants in Carlton
More in Carlton
Best Asian restaurants in Carlton
Italian by city
Best Italian restaurants in Melbourne
Italian by city
Best Italian restaurants in New York
Italian by city
Best Italian restaurants in Sydney
Italian by city
Best Italian restaurants in Brisbane
Italian by city
Best Italian restaurants in Adelaide
Italian by city
Best Italian restaurants in Brisbane City