Review guide
The evidence behind the best pizza in Haymarket
This guide dives deeper than just a ranking, exploring why City Oltra is Haymarket's go-to for pizza. We’ve analysed over 2500 reviews to uncover what makes their offering so popular, revealing the key elements that have resonated with locals and visitors alike.
Reviews
2,541+
Restaurants
4
Updated
2026-08-07
Why the winner leads
Why City Oltra ranks #1 for Pizza
City Oltra’s pizza is proving a serious hit in Haymarket, with diners frequently praising its generous toppings and perfectly crisp base. Many reviewers noted the value for money, particularly those seeking a satisfying and flavourful meal without breaking the bank. This pizza style seems best suited to casual groups and families looking for a relaxed dining experience, offering a solid choice for a weeknight treat or weekend catch-up. The restaurant's commitment to fresh mozzarella is also a standout feature. Reviewers consistently praised City Oltra’s pizza for its balanced flavour profiles and satisfyingly crispy crust.
- Reviewers highlighted the generous toppings as a key selling point
- The perfectly crisp base was repeatedly cited as a positive feature
- Many appreciated the value for money, making it an accessible option
How the shortlist compares
Where the other top Pizza Spots Stand Out
While City Oltra takes the crown, HAYMARKET KEBABS, Kebab Halal and Sydney City Kebabs are also strong contenders for pizza in Haymarket. HAYMARKET KEBABS consistently earned mentions, suggesting a popular choice amongst locals. Kebab Halal and Sydney City Kebabs were similarly well-regarded within their smaller review pools. These establishments offer distinct options – kebabs alongside their pizzas – demonstrating the diverse culinary scene of Haymarket.
- HAYMARKET KEBABS receives a higher number of mentions, indicating broader appeal
- Kebab Halal and Sydney City Kebabs provide alternative choices within Haymarket's food landscape
How to choose
Choosing Pizza in Haymarket
If you’re looking for a relaxed evening with friends or family, City Oltra is an excellent choice. Their pizza's balance of flavour and that satisfyingly crispy crust align perfectly with casual dining preferences. Considering the volume of positive reviews and the focus on fresh ingredients, it represents a reliable option. If you’re in the mood for a kebab alongside your meal, HAYMARKET KEBABS provides that added dimension.
- City Oltra is ideal for relaxed group meals and family gatherings
- Prioritise freshness and flavour with City Oltra's pizza selection