← New searchThe winner · Analysed 1,497 reviews● Updated 2026-05-12
Best Pizza in Brooklyn
pizza in New York came down to 81,133 reviews across 37 restaurants. The Pie Guy Pizza stood out for crispy crust and fresh toppings.
Italian · Brooklyn
33 Havemeyer St, Brooklyn, NY 11211, United States
Best Pizza
Reviewers consistently praise the thin, charred crust and the perfect balance of high-quality ingredients in every flavorful bite. While not the top-ranked spot, this iconic Williamsburg pizzeria offers a legendary experience that satisfies even the most seasoned travelers.
Winner Verdict
Overwhelmingly PositiveScore
7.4
Mentions
38
Sentiment
95%
“Been dreaming of the day I’d get to step foot inside this Iconic Pizzeria! Literally could have come to New York and only had a slice here and have been content! For the better part of the last decade I’ve watched Frank travel around the pizza world and have been jealous lol and this was my chance to see if this slice was as epic as I’d hopes! Gott”
— Ryan Naman
Restaurant details
Plan the visit
Hours
Closed - Opens 11 am
Address
33 Havemeyer St, Brooklyn, NY 11211, United States
Phone
+1 718-599-2210
Plus code
P28W+6J Brooklyn, New York, USA
Updated by this business 8 weeks ago
Why this ranking is reliable
Dated Review Activity (last 24 months)
Overwhelmingly PositiveReviews Analysed
1,497+
Restaurants Evaluated
1
Sentiment Score
95%
Data-backed ranking updated 2026-05-12
Runners up
Top 1 around Brooklyn
Sources
1 reviews from Google, blogs, Reddit and food guides.
Signal
38 mentions of "Pizza" tied to Best Pizza.
Score
Weighted by recency, sentiment polarity and authority of the source.