← New searchThe winner · Analysed 1,220 reviews● Updated 2026-05-12
Best Steak in Brooklyn
steak in New York came down to 127,802 reviews across 54 restaurants. Golden Steer at One Fifth stood out for perfectly cooked steak and creamy mac and cheese.
International · Brooklyn
355 Metropolitan Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11211, United States
St. Anselm
The butcher and ax handle steaks consistently earn high marks for their incredible flavor and quality. While not the top-ranked spot, the restaurant remains a premier choice because of its exceptional service and standout appetizers like clams and steak tartare.
Winner Verdict
Overwhelmingly PositiveScore
7.3
Mentions
27
Sentiment
96%
“It’s all so good. Not one bad dish ordered. We got the bacon, clams (omg) and the Caesar as apps. We all got our own steaks for the mains and shared spinach, mashed potatoes, and fingerling potatoes as sides. Everything was delish. Standouts were the butchers steak, mashed potatoes, clams, and spinach. The cheesecake and the sticky toffee pudding f”
— Maddy Land
Why this ranking is reliable
Dated Review Activity (last 24 months)
Overwhelmingly PositiveReviews Analysed
1,220+
Restaurants Evaluated
1
Sentiment Score
96%
Data-backed ranking updated 2026-05-12
Runners up
Top 1 around Brooklyn
Sources
1 reviews from Google, blogs, Reddit and food guides.
Signal
27 mentions of "Steak" tied to St. Anselm.
Score
Weighted by recency, sentiment polarity and authority of the source.