Review guide
The evidence behind the best scallops in Docklands
This guide delves deeper than just a ranking, exploring why Pier17 Bar & Grill Restaurant in Docklands Melbourne has become the go-to spot for exceptional scallops. We’ve analysed over 3400 reviews to uncover what makes their grilled scallops so consistently praised and how they stack up against other popular choices in this waterfront location.
Reviews
3,406+
Restaurants
4
Updated
2026-08-07
Why the winner leads
Why Pier17 Bar & Grill ranks #1 for Scallops
Pier17 Bar & Grill’s scallops are a clear standout, consistently lauded for their perfectly seared exterior and tender, sweet interior. Reviewers particularly enjoyed the generous portion size coupled with a rich, buttery sauce that enhanced the seafood's flavour profile beautifully. The AI blurb accurately reflects this sentiment: ‘a real highlight of the menu.’ Customers appreciate the refined yet relaxed dining experience offered alongside quality seafood, perfect for an evening out or a special occasion by the water. The restaurant’s focus on delivering well-prepared, flavourful grilled scallops is a key reason for its success.
- Reviewers noted the ‘perfectly seared exterior and tender, sweet interior’ of the scallops
- The generous portion size, combined with the rich, buttery sauce, was frequently praised
- Customers described it as ideal for a relaxed evening out or a special occasion
How the shortlist compares
Where the other top Scallops spots stand out
Fish N Chips on Docks and Butcher’s Prime Restaurant both offer strong scallop options in Docklands, though they don't quite match Pier17 Bar & Grill's focus on a refined seafood experience. Fish N Chips on Docks is a popular choice for classic fish and chips with scallops, leveraging its waterfront location. Butcher’s Prime Restaurant offers a more upscale steakhouse setting, featuring scallops as part of their broader menu and emphasizing prime cuts of meat alongside them. Steakhouse Grill 66 Docklands provides a similarly modern grill experience, showcasing scallops within a comprehensive selection of grilled dishes.
- Fish N Chips on Docks excels at delivering traditional fish and chips with added scallops
- Butcher’s Prime Restaurant offers scallops in a more sophisticated steakhouse environment
- Steakhouse Grill 66 showcases scallops within a broader selection of grilled menu options
How to choose
Choosing Scallops in Docklands
Considering your preferences is key. If you're after a relaxed evening with high-quality seafood and a sophisticated atmosphere, Pier17 Bar & Grill is the clear choice. For a classic fish and chips experience featuring scallops, Fish N Chips on Docks remains a solid option. If you’re looking for a more upscale setting alongside premium meat dishes, Butcher’s Prime Restaurant might suit your tastes better. Ultimately, each restaurant offers delicious grilled scallops; it comes down to personal preference.
- Choose Pier17 Bar & Grill for a refined seafood experience and relaxed atmosphere
- Opt for Fish N Chips on Docks for classic fish and chips with added scallops
- Select Butcher’s Prime Restaurant if you prefer a sophisticated steakhouse setting