← New searchThe winner · Analysed 21,678 reviews● Updated 2026-05-06
Best Porterhouse steakin Melbourne
International · Melbourne
Blacksmith Bar & Grill
Reviewers are unanimous that the grass-fed porterhouse steak is an exceptionally juicy and tender masterpiece, boasting a perfectly cooked texture that defines premium dining. This smoky porterhouse steak excels through its heavy seasoning and rich toppings, specifically the decadent red wine jus and savory mushroom sauce that elevate every bite.
Winner Verdict
Overwhelmingly PositiveScore
7.5
Mentions
6
Sentiment
100%
“Stopped in for the steak frites lunch special and wow, what a treat. The grass‑fed porterhouse was perfectly cooked – juicy, tender, and honestly one of the best steaks I’ve had in Melbourne. …”
— higher兄弟
Why It Won
What Reviewers Repeatedly Call Out
Reviewers are unanimous that the grass-fed porterhouse steak is an exceptionally juicy and tender masterpiece, boasting a perfectly cooked texture that defines premium dining. This smoky porterhouse steak excels through its heavy seasoning and rich toppings, specifically the decadent red wine jus and savory mushroom sauce that elevate every bite. While many venues struggle with consistency, Blacksmith Bar & Grill dominates the Melbourne scene by delivering this high-end flavor profile at an unbeatable lunch value.
Why this ranking is reliable
Review Activity (last 24 months)
Very PositiveReviews Analysed
21,678+
Restaurants Evaluated
21
Sentiment Score
100%
Data-backed ranking updated 2026-05-06
Runners up
Top 21 around Melbourne
- 02
Langlands Restaurant and Bar
The porterhouse steak is consistently praised for being perfectly cooked and amazing.
4 mentions
7.4
↓ - 03
Steak and soul
Reviewers consistently rave about the exceptional quality of the grassfed porterhouse steak, noting an absolute love for its rich flavor.
1 mentions
7.3
↓ - 04
Normandy Wine & Grill
Reviewers consistently praise the high-quality Wagyu MS7+ porterhouse available on the special board, noting its impressive marbling and flavor.
2 mentions
7.2
↓ - 05
Vlado's Charcoal Grill
Vlado's Charcoal Grill earns its high rank through perfectly executed porterhouse steaks that satisfy even seasoned international travelers.
4 mentions
7.2
↓ - 06
Flint
Reviewers rave about the incredible quality of the wagyu porterhouse, often calling it the best they have ever experienced.
1 mentions
7.1
↓ - 07
Marbl Steakhouse Port Melbourne
Reviewers consistently praise the delicious porterhouse steak for its rich, flavorful fat content and high-quality preparation.
2 mentions
7.1
↓ - 08
Restaurant 1903
Reviewers consistently praise the tender Southern Ranges porterhouse steak for its high quality and impressive texture.
2 mentions
7.1
↓ - 09
Butcher's Prime Restaurant
Reviewers consistently praise the perfectly cooked porterhouse steak, especially when paired with their incredibly creamy mashed potatoes.
1 mentions
7.0
↓ - 10
Charcoal Grill on The Hill
While the porterhouse can occasionally be slightly chewy, the steak remains a beautiful choice for meat lovers.
1 mentions
7.0
↓ - 11
France-Soir
While the porterhouse steak is reliably cooked to perfection, some cuts may contain unpalatable sinew.
2 mentions
7.0
↓ - 12
Ishiya Japanese Stonegrill
Reviewers consistently praise the porterhouse steak for its exceptional freshness and impressive flavor during the stonegrill experience.
1 mentions
7.0
↓ - 13
Macelleria Moonee Ponds the butcher that cooks for you
The porterhouse steak impresses with a beautiful char and deep richness, especially when paired with silky mashed potatoes and melting garlic butter.
1 mentions
7.0
↓ - 14
Macelleria Richmond butcher that cooks for you
Reviewers consistently praise the flavorful sausages and perfectly cooked vegetables that accompany the porterhouse steak.
1 mentions
7.0
↓ - 15
Mama Nuoi
Mama Nuoi earns its high ranking because the porterhouse steak delivers an amazing experience that stands out among the best Vietnamese options in Melbourne.
145 Nepean Hwy, Aspendale VIC 3195, Australia
1 mentions
7.0
↓ - 16
Matilda 159 Domain
The charred porterhouse steak delivers impressive flavor and is consistently cooked to perfection, making it a standout choice.
1 mentions
7.0
↓ - 17
New Quarter
New Quarter earns its high ranking with a signature porterhouse steak perfectly complemented by flavorful sate butter and fresh Asian greens.
79 Swan St, Richmond VIC 3121, Australia
1 mentions
7.0
↓ - 18
Palermo
Reviewers consistently praise the porterhouse steak as being exceptionally delicious and among the best they have ever tasted.
1 mentions
7.0
↓ - 19
Pretty Boy Bar & Restaurant
Reviewers consistently praise the high quality of the Angus beef porterhouse, noting its exceptional taste during dinner.
1 mentions
7.0
↓ - 20
Rare Steakhouse Downtown
Reviewers consistently praise the tender, flavorful, and perfectly cooked pasture-fed porterhouse for its high-quality presentation.
1 mentions
7.0
↓ - 21
Rare Steakhouse Midtown
Reviewers consistently praise the porterhouse steak for its exceptional quality, noting it is one of the best in Melbourne.
3 mentions
7.0
↓
Sources
32 reviews from Google, blogs, Reddit and food guides.
Signal
6 mentions of "porterhouse steak" tied to Blacksmith Bar & Grill.
Score
Weighted by recency, sentiment polarity and authority of the source.