← New searchThe winner · Analysed 518 reviews● Updated 2026-05-12
Best Pizza in New Hyde Park
pizza in New York came down to 81,133 reviews across 37 restaurants. The Pie Guy Pizza stood out for crispy crust and fresh toppings.
Italian · New Hyde Park
2048 Hillside Ave., New Hyde Park, NY 11040, United States
Eddie's Pizza
Diners rave about the incredible bar pies, specifically praising the addition of spicy cherry peppers and the unique fried eggplant pizza. While not ranked first, the restaurant offers deep historical charm and exceptionally attentive service that makes every visit worthwhile.
Winner Verdict
Mostly PositiveScore
8.0
Mentions
35
Sentiment
77%
“I been going to Eddie's since I was a little boy... no joke! My parents use to own a shop nearby and it was great, don't let this place fool you, looks like some typical pizza joint - nah, this place has some amazing history and is a bar pie place and has some amazing food. The chicken dishes are amazing, you can get cherry peppers on your bar pie”
— Jodie Simpson
Restaurant details
Plan the visit
Hours
Closed - Opens 11 am
Address
2048 Hillside Ave., New Hyde Park, NY 11040, United States
Phone
+1 516-354-9780
Plus code
Q82G+C3 New Hyde Park, New York, USA
Why this ranking is reliable
Dated Review Activity (last 24 months)
Mostly PositiveReviews Analysed
518+
Restaurants Evaluated
1
Sentiment Score
77%
Data-backed ranking updated 2026-05-12
Runners up
Top 1 around New Hyde Park
Sources
1 reviews from Google, blogs, Reddit and food guides.
Signal
35 mentions of "Pizza" tied to Eddie's Pizza.
Score
Weighted by recency, sentiment polarity and authority of the source.