Review guide
The evidence behind the best Fish & Chips in Melbourne
This guide dives deeper than just the rankings, uncovering why Ahoy Roy Fish and Chips has become Melbourne’s go-to for a classic Fish & Chips experience. We’ve analysed over 34,000 reviews to bring you the most compelling details about this beloved local favourite and how it stacks up against its top competitors.
Reviews
34,009+
Restaurants
21
Updated
2026-08-07
Why the winner leads
Why Ahoy Roy Fish and Chips ranks #1 for Fish & Chips
Ahoy Roy Fish and Chips has secured the top spot thanks to a combination of consistently high praise. Reviewers rave about its crispy, golden batter and juicy, fluffy fish, often attributing this to their use of premium cottonseed oil – minimising grease. Many appreciate the crunchy chips and salty flavour profile. The seaside location near the beach is also a major draw, complemented by a friendly atmosphere ideal for casual meals. Despite one diner noting a slightly thin fillet, the overall feedback consistently highlights a satisfying and flavourful experience.
- The use of premium cottonseed oil results in minimal oily residue – a key positive
- The clearest pattern in the excerpts is the crispy texture of the batter and chips
- A friendly atmosphere makes it suitable for dates or casual lunches near the beach
How the shortlist compares
Where the other top Fish & Chips spots stand out
Auburn Catch Fish & Chips also delivers on crispy, non-greasy batter and tasty seafood, bolstered by incredibly friendly service. However, recent ownership changes have introduced some challenges – reports of missing items and a decline in quality are emerging. Beluga Fish & Chippery South Yarra is known for its reliable consistency, moist fish and perfectly cooked potato cakes, but occasional soft batter issues exist. Eastwood Fish & Chips prides itself on fresh ingredients and generous service, yet inconsistencies with gravy and chip textures present challenges. Fish N Chips on Docks offers waterfront views and delicious flavours, though some find the chip portions slightly small. Finally, Fish ‘N’ Grill excels at handmade potato cakes and light ba
- Auburn Catch's recent changes present potential quality concerns for new customers
- Beluga Fish & Chippery South Yarra’s occasional soft batter issues warrant consideration
- Eastwood Fish & Chips’ gravy and chip inconsistencies may be a drawback
How to choose
Choosing Fish & Chips in Melbourne
When selecting your Fish & Chips, consider what matters most. If you prioritize a consistently enjoyable and flavourful experience with minimal grease, Ahoy Roy is the clear choice based on extensive reviews. Those seeking exceptionally friendly service should look to Auburn Catch. If reliable quality and moist fish are essential, Beluga Fish & Chippery South Yarra remains a solid option. However, be mindful of potential inconsistencies – particularly regarding batter texture and gravy consistency across all establishments.
- Prioritise Ahoy Roy for consistently high-quality, flavourful fish and chips with minimal grease
- Choose Auburn Catch if exceptionally friendly service is your top priority
- Consider Beluga Fish & Chippery South Yarra for reliable quality and moist fish