Review guide
The evidence behind the best fish soup in Melbourne
Melbourne’s fish soup scene is brimming with delicious options, and this guide dives deeper than just the rankings to uncover why Fishing Season Catch and Cook consistently delivers a standout experience. We've analysed over 14,000 reviews to pinpoint the best places for a warming bowl of seafood goodness.
Reviews
14,458+
Restaurants
14
Updated
2026-08-07
Why the winner leads
Why Fishing Season Catch and Cook ranks #1 for Fish Soup
Fishing Season Catch and Cook’s fish soup is consistently lauded as a rich, intensely flavoured experience. Reviewers highlight the generous portions and satisfying heartiness, making it ideal for a cool Melbourne evening or those seeking comfort. A key element is the use of lemongrass, frequently mentioned as contributing significantly to the soup's flavour profile. Many reviewers appreciated the focus on quality ingredients and classic seafood flavours. The restaurant appears popular with families and groups looking for a robust, uncomplicated meal.
- Reviewers noted the ‘rich, deeply flavourful broth brimming with fresh seafood’ as a key selling point
- Generous portions and satisfying heartiness were frequently mentioned in positive reviews
- The use of lemongrass was a consistent element praised for enhancing the soup's taste
How the shortlist compares
Where the other top Fish Soup Spots Stand Out
Several restaurants offer compelling fish soups in Melbourne. Thien Kim is a strong contender, with reviews often focusing on its overall quality. Co Tham Can Tho and Argo Fishop also receive positive attention for their flavourful broths and satisfying portions. Fishpot and Huy's Kitchen are frequently mentioned, indicating considerable local support, while Red Cliff offers a traditional approach appreciated by some. These establishments demonstrate the diverse approaches to perfecting this classic dish.
- Thien Kim receives praise for its overall quality and consistently positive reviews
- Co Tham Can Tho and Argo Fishop stand out for their flavourful broths and generous servings
- Fishpot and Huy’s Kitchen enjoy strong local support, suggesting a loyal following
How to choose
Choosing Fish Soup in Melbourne
When selecting your fish soup, consider what you're craving. Fishing Season Catch and Cook excels with its intensely flavoured broth and generous portions – perfect for a hearty meal. Alternatively, Thien Kim offers a consistently high-quality experience, while Co Tham Can Tho and Argo Fishop provide similarly satisfying options based on reviews. Prioritise restaurants with fresh seafood and classic flavour profiles for the most authentic Melbourne fish soup.
- Look for restaurants that emphasise fresh seafood and bold flavours for a truly satisfying bowl
- Consider your group size – Fishing Season Catch and Cook is particularly well-suited to families and groups