Review guide
The evidence behind the best tomahawk steak in New York
This guide dives deeper than just the rankings, exploring what makes the tomahawk steak experience in New York truly special. We’ve analysed over 31,000 reviews to pinpoint the best spots for this indulgent treat, focusing on the key factors diners consistently praised – size, quality, and presentation.
Reviews
31,286+
Restaurants
8
Updated
2026-08-07
Why the winner leads
Why Empire Steak House - Midtown East ranks #1 for tomahawk steak
Empire Steak House in Midtown East has earned its top spot with a truly impressive offering. the review evidence points to the sheer size of their tomahawk steaks, often described as ‘seriously impressive spectacles’ due to the generous portions presented dramatically on the bone. Guests rave about the quality and flavour of the beef, frequently noting its tenderness and robust seasoning. The experience is geared towards celebration; many describe it as ideal for groups seeking a memorable indulgence. The restaurant's opulent atmosphere further enhances this lavish meal.
- Guests appreciate the substantial size and generous portions offered
- The quality of the beef, particularly its tenderness and seasoning, is consistently praised
- Reviewers describe the experience as perfect for celebratory occasions or special meals
How the shortlist compares
Where the other top tomahawk steak spots stand out
While Empire Steak House - Midtown East takes the lead, several other establishments offer excellent tomahawk steaks. Gallagher’s Steakhouse NYC is known for its traditional atmosphere and consistently high-quality meat, with reviewers noting a strong focus on classic preparation. Palermo Argentinian Bistro – NYC distinguishes itself through authentic Argentinian cuts and grilling techniques. Peter Luger Steak House remains a stalwart institution, celebrated for its dry-aged beef and old-school service. Rocco Steakhouse offers a vibrant environment alongside solid steaks, while St. Anselm provides a more intimate setting with high-quality meat.
- Gallagher’s Steakhouse NYC prioritises traditional preparation and a classic steakhouse vibe
- Peter Luger Steak House is renowned for its dry-aged beef and historic atmosphere
How to choose
Choosing tomahawk steak in New York
Ultimately, the best tomahawk steak for you depends on your priorities. If a truly grand spectacle and generous portions are key, Empire Steak House - Midtown East is the clear winner. However, if you’re seeking an authentic Argentinian experience, Palermo Argentinian Bistro – NYC might be preferable. For a more traditional and historic setting, Peter Luger Steak House remains a strong contender. Consider your desired atmosphere and flavour profile when making your selection.
- Prioritise size and spectacle: Empire Steak House - Midtown East is the obvious choice
- Seek an authentic experience: Palermo Argentinian Bistro – NYC offers distinctive flavours