BiteRanked← New search

Our pick · 5 ranked candidates● Updated 2026-09-02

Best Burgers in South Yarra

Compare 5 ranked candidates for Burgers in South Yarra, using the available dish evidence. Check the mentions, coverage and venue details before choosing.

Plan your visit to Benny's American Burger

560 Chapel St, South Yarra VIC 3141

Restaurant price range: $20-40 per person. This is not a verified price for Burgers. Confirm opening hours and dish availability before travelling.

Get directionsCompare alternativesUnderstand the evidence

The verdict at a glance

Top 5 for Burgers in South Yarra

  1. 1Benny's American BurgerSouth YarraBenny’s American Burger in South Yarra is delivering satisfying Burgers, with many commenting on the generous...7.5
  2. 2No.1 Old London SeafoodSouth YarraNo.7.5
  3. 3Beluga Fish & Chippery South YarraSouth YarraBeluga Fish & Chippery South Yarra is a top-rated spot for Burgers in South Yarra.7.4
  4. 4Wagyu YaSouth YarraWagyu Ya is a top-rated spot for Burgers in South Yarra.7.0
  5. 5YakikamiSouth YarraYakikami is a top-rated spot for Burgers in South Yarra.7.0
#1 Ranked
01

American · South Yarra

560 Chapel St, South Yarra VIC 3141

Benny's American Burger

Benny’s American Burger in South Yarra is delivering satisfying Burgers, with many commenting on the generous patties and quality of beef. Several reviewers noted a tendency for the burgers to be quite juicy, requiring careful handling to avoid messy eating – a consideration for those dining solo or with children. This bustling restaurant seems best suited for groups seeking classic American fare and a relaxed atmosphere, offering hearty portions perfect for sharing.

Winner Verdict

Very Positive

Score

7.5

Mentions

16

Sentiment

81%

Plan the visit

Website

Price

$20-40 per person (281 reports)

Phone

03) 7046 6644

$20-40 per person

Dated dish reviews

How it holds over time

Trending stronger

Based on the recent feedback, Benny’s American Burger appears to be experiencing a noticeable lift in customer satisfaction, with a high proportion of positive reviews. The increased frequency of enthusiastic comments, particularly regarding the quality and preparation of their smashed beef burgers and other items like the chips, suggests a positive trend for the restaurant.

1–4 years ago

67%

positive across 6 dated dish reviews

Last 12 months

90%

positive across 10 dated dish reviews

Evidence behind this ranking

Updated 2026-09-02

Collected review count: not separately recorded for every candidate in this ranking.

Dated Review Activity (last 24 months)

Very Positive

14 of 32 mentions have usable recent dates (0 undated, 18 older).

PositiveNegative

This dataset contains 5 ranked candidates and 2,193 source-listed restaurant reviews. That total includes other dishes and is not the number of review texts collected. 16 recorded dish mentions are associated with Benny's American Burger. Coverage is incomplete; a ranking is not a firsthand review.

How scores, review counts and update dates work →

Runners up

Top 5 around South Yarra

Review guide

The evidence behind the best Burgers in South Yarra

This guide expands the ranking into the review patterns behind the best Burgers in South Yarra, using only pages with enough restaurant and review signal to support a fuller breakdown.

Reviews

2,193+

Restaurants

5

Updated

2026-09-02

Why the winner leads

Why Benny's American Burger ranks #1 for Burgers

Benny’s American Burger in South Yarra is delivering satisfying Burgers, with many commenting on the generous patties and quality of beef. Several reviewers noted a tendency for the burgers to be quite juicy, requiring careful handling to avoid messy eating – a consideration for those dining solo or with children. This bustling restaurant seems best suited for groups seeking classic American fare and a relaxed atmosphere, offering hearty portions perfect for sharing.

How the shortlist compares

Where the other top Burgers spots stand out

The rest of the ranking still matters because Burgers searches are rarely one-size-fits-all. These are the clearest review-backed differences among the next-best places.

  • No.1 Old London Seafood: No.
  • Beluga Fish & Chippery South Yarra: Beluga Fish & Chippery South Yarra is a top-rated spot for Burgers in South Yarra.
  • Wagyu Ya: Wagyu Ya is a top-rated spot for Burgers in South Yarra.
  • Yakikami: Yakikami is a top-rated spot for Burgers in South Yarra.

How to choose

Choosing Burgers in South Yarra

Use this ranking as a shortlist, not just a winner announcement: Benny's American Burger is the strongest overall signal, while the runners up show where reviewers found different strengths across South Yarra.

  • 2,193 source-listed restaurant reviews are associated with 5 ranked candidates; these are not all collected review texts.
  • Benny's American Burger has 16 Burgers mentions and a 81% sentiment score.
  • The current review verdict is very positive.
Search another dish→

Quick answers

Frequently asked questions

What is the best Burgers in South Yarra?

Benny's American Burger in South Yarra is currently ranked #1 for Burgers in South Yarra, among 5 candidates in our available dataset. Benny’s American Burger in South Yarra is delivering satisfying Burgers, with many commenting on the generous patties and quality of beef. Several reviewers noted a tendency for the burgers to be quite juicy, requiring careful handling to avoid messy eating – a consideration for those dining solo or with children.

Which other Burgers places in South Yarra come close?

No.1 Old London Seafood, Beluga Fish & Chippery South Yarra, Wagyu Ya round out the top of the ranking. Each earned strong dish-specific praise in recent reviews — the full shortlist below covers 5 ranked restaurants.

How is the best Burgers in South Yarra decided?

BiteRanked compares candidates using available restaurant ratings and dish mentions. Listing review totals are not collected review counts. Coverage is incomplete; the recorded ranking update is 2026-09-02. Read our methodology for scoring and limitations.