← New searchThe winner · Analysed 556 reviews● Updated 2026-05-12
Best Burgers in Fitzroy
After scrutinising 44,813 reviews across 58 Melbourne establishments, Burger Shack emerged as the city's premier burger destination. Diners consistently highlight the incredible freshness of the ingredients and the impressive rooftop atmosphere.
American · Fitzroy
293 Brunswick St, Fitzroy VIC 3065
Benny's American Burger - Fitzroy
Reviewers consistently praise the juicy, flavorful patties paired with soft, fluffy buns and perfectly crispy fries. While not the top-ranked spot, the restaurant remains a standout choice due to its impressive selection of tap beers and thoughtfully crafted vegetarian options.
Winner Verdict
Overwhelmingly PositiveScore
7.5
Mentions
19
Sentiment
100%
“Benny’s Burger never disappoints! The burgers are juicy, full of flavour, and made with super fresh ingredients. The buns are soft, the fries are perfectly crispy, and the whole meal just hits the spot every time. Service is friendly and fast, and you can tell the team takes real pride in what they do. If you’re craving a top-notch burger, Benny’s”
— Punit Fernandes
Why this ranking is reliable
Dated Review Activity (last 24 months)
Overwhelmingly PositiveReviews Analysed
556+
Restaurants Evaluated
1
Sentiment Score
100%
Data-backed ranking updated 2026-05-12
Runners up
Top 1 around Fitzroy
Sources
1 reviews from Google, blogs, Reddit and food guides.
Signal
19 mentions of "Burgers" tied to Benny's American Burger - Fitzroy.
Score
Weighted by recency, sentiment polarity and authority of the source.