Review guide
The evidence behind the best Burgers in Carlton
This guide dives deeper than just a ranking of Carlton's best burgers, uncovering the reasons behind Sonnys Fried Chicken & Burgers’ dominance. We’ve analysed over 1188 reviews to pinpoint what makes this spot a standout choice for those craving a juicy, indulgent burger experience in the heart of Melbourne.
Reviews
1,188+
Restaurants
4
Updated
2026-08-07
Why the winner leads
Why Sonnys Fried Chicken & Burgers ranks #1 for Burgers
Sonnys Fried Chicken & Burgers has firmly established itself as Carlton’s go-to burger destination, largely due to consistently high praise for its generous portions and quality ingredients. Reviewers frequently highlight the juicy patties themselves, alongside a substantial amount of toppings. Many comments specifically mention the dripping sauces and plentiful fillings, leading to a decidedly messy but satisfying experience – reviewers recommend bringing napkins! The relaxed atmosphere and focus on American-style burgers make it a perfect choice for those seeking an uncomplicated meal. This Carlton institution is a favourite amongst locals.
- Reviewers frequently praised the quality of the meat used in Sonnys’ burgers
- Numerous comments noted the generous quantity of toppings, contributing to a messy but enjoyable experience
- The relaxed atmosphere and American-style burger focus appeal to many Carlton residents
How the shortlist compares
Where the other top Burgers stand out
Shish’d Lygon, Street Taste - Carlton and Nasi Lemak House all offer strong burger options in Carlton. Shish'd Lygon is a popular choice for its diverse menu and consistently good burgers, though reviews aren’t as focused on the patty itself. Street Taste – Carlton receives positive feedback for its accessible location and solid burger offerings, while Nasi Lemak House provides an alternative with its unique flavour profile. However, none of these places quite match Sonnys' focus on generous portions and indulgent fried chicken-based burgers.
- Shish’d Lygon boasts a diverse menu alongside their well-regarded burgers
- Street Taste – Carlton is known for its convenient location and reliable burger quality
How to choose
Choosing Burgers in Carlton
If you’re craving a satisfying, indulgent burger experience with plenty of flavour and generous portions, Sonnys Fried Chicken & Burgers is your best bet. Consider bringing some extra napkins! If you're specifically looking for diverse menu options, Shish’d Lygon might be worth exploring. For a convenient location and solid burger, Street Taste - Carlton is a good option. Ultimately, the right choice depends on your personal preference – are you prioritising quantity or variety?
- Prioritise generous portions and indulgent flavours with Sonnys
- Consider bringing extra napkins due to the messy nature of their burgers