← New searchThe winner · Analysed 19,319 reviews● Updated 2026-05-01
Best Pizzain Balmain
Italian restaurant · Sydney
Shop 2/338 Pitt St
Macchiato Wood Fire Pizza and Coffee Roasters
Casual Italian grill with rustic-chic decor and bare-brick walls, for wood-fired pizza, and coffee.
Score
8.7
Mentions
3
Sentiment
90%
“My gorgeous partner took me here for our anniversary and it was such a beautiful experience. The atmosphere was lively, very crowded with lots of chatter all around. But, it created such a nice, warm vibe. The $34 lasagna was absolutely incredible!! The sauce was rich, full of f”
— Tracey Waters
Why this ranking is reliable
Reviews Analysed
19,319+
Restaurants Evaluated
10
Sentiment Score
90%
Data-backed ranking updated 2026-05-01
Runners up
Top 10 in Balmain
- 02
Capriccio Osteria Italian Restaurant in Leichhardt Sydney
159 Norton St, Leichhardt
4 mentions
8.3
↓ - 03
City Oltra
Shop 11/1 Eddy Ave, Haymarket
5 mentions
8.2
↓ - 04
Pizza e Vino Glebe
331 Glebe Point Rd, Glebe
5 mentions
8.2
↓ - 05
Il Pacifico Pizza
50-58 Sir John Young Cres, Woolloomooloo
5 mentions
8.1
↓ - 06
Lilyfield Pizzeria Rosticceria
3 Orange Grove Plaza, Lilyfield
4 mentions
8.1
↓ - 07
La Botte D'Oro Restaurant
137 Marion St, Leichhardt
2 mentions
8.0
↓ - 08
Calico - Cafe, Restaurant, Pizzeria & Bar
146 Abercrombie St, Redfern
1 mentions
8.0
↓ - 09
Farina Pizzeria Crows Nest
104 Willoughby Rd, Crows Nest
2 mentions
7.9
↓ - 10
Bravo Trattoria
59 Willoughby Rd, Crows Nest
3 mentions
7.8
↓
Sources
10 reviews from Google, blogs, Reddit and food guides.
Signal
3 mentions of "pizza" tied to Macchiato Wood Fire Pizza and Coffee Roasters.
Score
Weighted by recency, sentiment polarity and authority of the source.